We have covered a lot of ground so far in looking over the
literature on ketosis and ketogenesis.
We have seen what ketone bodies our body actually uses, and how they are
regulated on many levels.
We already know that a high-fat diet is a great way to induce
ketogenesis. However a question
many of you may be asking is “Do all fats have the same ketogenic
potential?” Well, the answer to
that is no, some fats are better at inducing ketogenesis than others. The most ketogenic fats we have are the
medium-chain fats.
We consume many different kinds of fats, and all these fats
vary in two different ways, chain length and saturation. Saturation refers to the number of
double bonds a fatty acid chain has, with no double bonds being a saturated
fat, and one or more double bonds being an unsaturated fat. The medium-chain fatty acids we will
talk about here are all saturated fatty acids. They are called medium-chain because they have between 6 and
12 carbons in their chain (1). Here are a couple of diagrams of some
of these medium-chain fats.
Caproic/Hexanoic Acid
Caprylic/Octanoic Acid
Lauric/Dodecanoic Acid
We usually refer to these as medium-chain triglycerides, because we usually encounter them in the triglyceride state, which just means we have three of the above fatty acid chains connected to a glycerol molecule to keep them together.
What makes these fats so ketogenic? Well it all comes down to the special
properties they have based on chain length and saturation.
Absorption
and Liver processing
Medium-chain triglycerides (MCTs) are preferentially dealt
with by pancreatic lipases in our small intestines (2). This means that they will be
broken down into individual medium-chain fatty acids (MCFAs) first, which is
the state they need to be in to be absorbed. Not only are they preferentially broken down, but also they
are absorbed into the portal vein and transported straight to the liver. This is in direct contrast with other
fats, as they are absorbed by the lymphatic system and travel through the
periphery before reaching the liver.
This has the distinct of advantage of making MCTs unable to be stored by
adipose tissue, since they never encounter the tissue.
Once in the liver MCFAs are able to cross the mitochondrial
membrane without the need for a special transport molecule. Once inside of the mitochondria, their
even number chain lengths facilitate their rapid breakdown into acetyl-CoAs (2). As we have seen time
and time again, the production of acetyl-CoA is absolutely necessary for ketogenesis. These new acetyl-CoAs are mainly
destined to become ketone bodies, however as with all ketone body generation it
is still dependent on low levels of oxaloacetate, as we can see from this
abstract (3).
So, as we can see from our biochemistry, MCTs are easily
turned into ketone bodies by our liver and then sent out to the periphery for
use. While other fats can be
turned into ketone bodies, none of them have the unique characteristics that
MCTs do that make them ideal for ketone body creation.
I found one nice study that discusses a lot of the questions
still out there about MCTs, like how ketogenic are they alone, and when eaten
with other foods, especially glucose.
The first experiment gave rats either 10mL/kg body weight MCT oil or
corn oil, and looked at their ketone levels (4). Rats in the MCT
oil group had ketone body levels that increased by as much as 22 fold over 4
hours after treatment. Also the
treatment with MCTs was shown to increase ketone levels in as little as 30 minutes
after treatment. However, the rats
given the corn oil only managed to increase ketone body levels 2 fold over the
same time period. With this data
alone we can see the ketogenic power of MCTs.
Now how about what happens when you give these same rats some
glucose with these fat treatments? In the next experiment from the same paper
the authors gave 3.75g/kg body weight glucose to the rats, in addition to
5mL/kg body weight MCT or corn oil.
We can see from this graph that while we do get a
significant amount of total ketone body production, we get nowhere near the 22
fold increase we saw with just the MCT treatment. However, I think this level
still constitutes a ketosis state.
Summary
Well I think that was pretty much all I wanted to cover with
MCTs and ketosis. We can see
through the biochemistry that MCFAs are ideal for producing ketones in liver
mitochondria. This is because they
are preferentially sent to the liver through the portal vein, they readily
cross the mitochondrial membrane, and are easily broken into acetyl-CoA since
they are even numbered chains.
Also, we have seen just how ketogenic MCTs are, and can increase ketone
body levels up to 22 fold in rats.
Also, they are still able to induce ketosis when glucose is present,
which is something we have not seen with the other ways we know to enter
ketosis.
We will wrap up this series next time with how ketogenic
diets can be therapeutic, and in what cases. Then, finally, we will end with my practical
recommendations.
At the risk of showing my ignorance, don't all three of the diagrams of MCT's you show have double-bonds with Oxygen?
ReplyDeleteWhat type of fat is corn oil?
What are some examples of saturated MCT's?
Actually, that is a great question, I had not thought of that. When they talk about the double bonds in a fatty acids they only refer to double bonds between carbon atoms. So each line in those diagrams represents a bond between two carbons, so if one of those were a double then it would be unsaturated. Here is a link the the DHA wiki page for an example (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Docosahexaenoic_acid). You can see all the double bonds in the chain in that one! The end of each fat is a special functional group that is used for reacting, and is found in EVERY fatty acid, so it doesn't really count for determining the special properties of fat.
DeleteAlso, with this information, it can now be seen that all of the three fatty acids displayed are indeed saturated MCTs. In fact, there are no unsaturated MCTs.
They used the corn oil because it is a pretty standard long-chain fatty acid (LCFA), which because it is longer, has different properties than our MCFAs. This table has more specifics about the actual fats found in corn oil http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_oil.
This article is really well done, do you mind if I link and accredit it on my website, for an article on MCT's and Ketogenic Diets?
DeleteYeah, go for it.
Delete